Marshalls Wins Privacy Lawsuit Over Email Tracking Pixels

A federal judge has ruled in favor of TJX Companies, the parent company of Marshalls, T.J. Maxx, and HomeGoods, in a privacy lawsuit alleging the retailer violated Arizona law by embedding tracking pixels in promotional emails. U.S. District Court Judge Allison Burroughs dismissed the case, stating that the plaintiff, Arlette Campos, failed to demonstrate a concrete injury. Campos claimed the pixels collected sensitive data, such as email open rates, recipient locations, and reading times, without her consent, allegedly breaching Arizona’s Telephone, Utility and Communication Service Records Act.

However, Burroughs noted that Campos willingly provided her email address to receive the messages, and the content of the emails was not private. TJX argued that the Arizona law was intended to prevent “pretexting” — impersonating customers to access records — rather than targeting standard email marketing practices. The company warned that interpreting the law as Campos suggested would render nearly all emails to Arizona residents unlawful. This case is part of a broader wave of lawsuits against retailers like H&M and Home Depot, which have also successfully defended similar claims. The dismissal marks a significant win for TJX, but the legal battle over email tracking practices continues. Ivonne Carbajal, who sued Home Depot under the same Arizona law, has appealed her case to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, signalling that the debate over digital privacy and email marketing is far from over.
Source